Regulatory Coherence and the Multilateral Trade System: Lessons from RTAs and Lessons to Promote Convergence

March 28, 2017

On March 28th, 2017, the International Centre for Trade and Sustainable Development (ICTSD) and the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) organised a dialogue on “Regulatory Coherence and the Multilateral Trade System: Lessons from RTAs and Options to Promote Convergence” as part of the RTA Exchange dialogue series aimed at systematically exploring possibilities for convergence and coherence-building between regional trade agreements (RTAs) and the multilateral trade system. With the importance of tariffs declining because of autonomous liberalisation of RTA commitments, the policies that inhibit international trade flows are increasingly of a regulatory nature. Differences in objectives, implementation and enforcement in regulatory regimes may imply additional costs for foreign firms, particularly those from developing countries, desiring to enter global markets as they will need to satisfy regulatory norms in each country they operate in.

 

While the WTO includes some disciplines regarding regulatory policies, most notably in the area of mandatory product standards (SPS/TBT), most of the rules and mechanisms that determine how to collaborate on regulatory policies takes place outside the ambit of trade frameworks. In recent years however, innovative provisions and mechanisms to cooperate are increasingly integrated into modern deep integration agreements. While such cooperation might foster common standards or conformity assessment procedures that reduce transaction costs, some fear that the development of new standards in the context of such cooperation schemes might discriminate against third countries and non-parties and set the bar too high for poorer countries.

 

Taking into consideration this context, the objective of this dialogue is to analyse the role of trade agreements (particularly modern RTAs) in facilitating the various approaches to international regulatory cooperation and examine the tensions arising between RTAs and the multilateral trade system, and potentially amongst RTAs themselves.


Agenda: Link


RTA

RTA

Dialogue Report and Background Materials

The dialogue opened by mapping the different approaches through which regulatory cooperation is happening at the international level, assessing the role of trade agreements in these various approaches, and identifying some of the resultant cross-border externalities faced by key stakeholders, particularly in developing countries. The afternoon sessions then reviewed the development of innovative provisions and mechanisms for regulatory cooperation that are emerging from recent modern deep integration initiatives and considered what can be learned in order to promote new approaches at the multilateral level. Through this analysis, we aim to develop concrete policy recommendations of best practices which could be replicated and put forth specific ideas to be harvested for the multilateral trade system.


RTA

The Role of Regulatory Cooperation in the Future of the WTO

Thomas Bollyky

The emergence of global value chains (GVCs) and global public goods presents an opportunity for the World Trade Organization (WTO) to play a larger role in international regulatory cooperation. This paper identifies the circumstances and modalities where the WTO is most likely to be successful. First, it assesses the circumstances in which international regulatory cooperation is best suited to be multilateralised through the WTO. Second, it considers the means by which regulatory cooperation should be pursued at the multilateral level. In particular, it recommends a hub and spoke model for promoting regulatory cooperation and maintaining the transparency and democratic accountability of that mechanism.

Read Full Material: Link

RTA

Regulator Considerations: Leveraging Opportunities through Regulatory Cooperation

Robert Carberry

This paper examines the opportunity that regulatory cooperation provides to rationalise the array of overlapping international regulatory systems going forward, and the role that trade agreements can play to facilitate this occurring, particularly with regard to lessons learned from the Canada-US regulatory cooperation effort. In so doing, the paper outlines the context for cooperation between regulators, the important role for stakeholders, the approach to regulatory cooperation planning, and potential trade agreement implications.

Read Full Material: Link

RTA

Bridging Distance for Development: Regulatory Cooperation Applied to Consumer Rights, Parcel Delivery and Sales Tax

Hanne Melin

This paper examines the need to encourage more widespread and inclusive participation of micro, small, and medium enterprises in global markets as a component of the Sustainable Development Goals. It puts forward recommendations on how international regulatory cooperation can take a central role in facilitating Internet-enabled trade.

Read Full Material: Link


In Other Dialogues

Upcoming: RTA Dispute Settlement Provisions: Options for Effective Enforcement

February 8, 2018

Together with the proliferation of regional trade agreements (RTAs), there has been a proliferation of dispute settlement mechanisms (DSMs) included in those agreements. While they are far from bei... READ MORE

Trade and Development Symposium

December 11, 2017

Digital Trade-Related Provisions in Regional Trade Agreements

July 13, 2017

On July 13th, 2017,  the International Centre for Trade and Sustainable Development (ICTSD) and the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) organised a dialogue on digital trade-related pro... READ MORE

Ensuring Sustainability through Trade Agreements

March 29, 2017

On March 29th, 2017, the ICTSD, with the support of the German Development Cooperation, organised a dialogue on “Ensuring Sustainability through Trade Agreements” under the RT... READ MORE

Towards Inclusive Rules of Origin

November 21, 2016

On November 21-22, 2016, the ICTSD in partnership with the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) organised a dialogue on inclusive rules of origin (RoO). The meeting represents the first in a serie... READ MORE